What is the Broken Window Fallacy?

What is the Broken Window Fallacy?

What is the Broken Window Fallacy? Jonathan Poland

The broken window fallacy refers to the idea that the economic benefits of destructive events, such as wars and natural disasters, are overstated. While the spending associated with these events can boost a nation’s GDP, this does not necessarily translate into real economic growth or prosperity. This is because the opportunity cost of such events is often overlooked.

For example, if a nation spends $1 trillion dollars on a war, this may stimulate the economy by paying soldiers and defense contractors. However, this does not take into account the fact that the same amount of money could have been used for other purposes that would have a greater stimulative effect on the economy, such as infrastructure projects or education and training programs.

In addition, destructive events often result in long-term economic costs, such as the loss of human lives, damage to infrastructure and natural resources, and increased debt. These costs can outweigh any short-term economic benefits and ultimately harm a nation’s overall economic prosperity. Overall, the broken window fallacy highlights the importance of considering the full economic costs and benefits of any policy or event, rather than focusing solely on the immediate impact on GDP.

The Parable of the Broken Window is a famous argument by political economist Frederic Bastiat, which was published in 1850. The parable tells the story of a shopkeeper whose shop window is broken by his son. Bastiat argues that the situation is good for the economy because the money spent on repairing the window stimulates economic activity. However, the parable then shows that this argument is a fallacy, as it ignores the opportunity cost of spending money on repairing the window. Specifically, the money that is spent on repairing the window could have been used in more productive ways, such as improving the shop or investing in other opportunities.

The parable highlights the importance of considering the full economic costs and benefits of any action, rather than focusing solely on the immediate effects on economic activity. It serves as a reminder that every decision has opportunity costs, and that it is important to carefully weigh these costs and benefits in order to make the most effective and efficient use of resources.

Learn More
Practical Thinking Jonathan Poland

Practical Thinking

Practical thinking is a type of thinking that focuses on finding timely and reasonable solutions to problems. This type of…

Loss Leader Jonathan Poland

Loss Leader

A loss leader is a product or service that is sold at a price below its cost in order to…

Investor Relations Jonathan Poland

Investor Relations

Investor relations (IR) is the process of managing the relationship between a company and its investors. This includes communicating with…

Branding 101 Jonathan Poland

Branding 101

Branding is the process of creating a unique and recognizable identity for a product, service, or business. This identity is…

What is Fandom? Jonathan Poland

What is Fandom?

Fandom refers to the subculture that develops around particular popular culture series or formats, such as films, television shows, characters,…

Ai Websites (Q3 2023) Jonathan Poland

Ai Websites (Q3 2023)

A simple resource dump of Ai websites we found during Q3 2023. Human AI Ethical, transparent, and beneficial AI development…

Product Launch Jonathan Poland

Product Launch

Product launch refers to the introduction of a new or updated product to a specific market. This is an important…

Automation Jonathan Poland


Automation refers to the use of technology to perform tasks that were previously done manually. In recent years, automation has…

Risk Prevention Jonathan Poland

Risk Prevention

Risk prevention is the process of identifying, assessing, and mitigating potential risks that may arise in a given situation. It…

Content Database

Search over 1,000 posts on topics across
business, finance, and capital markets.

Brand Awareness Jonathan Poland

Brand Awareness

Brand awareness refers to the extent to which consumers are familiar with and able to recognize a brand. It is…

Sales Pipeline Jonathan Poland

Sales Pipeline

A sales pipeline is a visual representation of the sales process, from the initial contact with a potential customer to…

Internal Branding Jonathan Poland

Internal Branding

Internal branding involves creating a strong brand identity within the company itself, rather than just focusing on marketing to customers.…

Risk Tolerance Jonathan Poland

Risk Tolerance

A risk is the possibility of an adverse event occurring, while a trigger is the root cause of that event.…

Professional Skills Jonathan Poland

Professional Skills

Professional skills are a combination of talents, abilities, knowledge, and character traits that are necessary for a person to be…

Brand Experience Jonathan Poland

Brand Experience

Brand experience refers to the overall perception and feelings that a consumer has while interacting with a brand. It includes…

Change Resistance Jonathan Poland

Change Resistance

Change resistance is the act of derailing, slowing down, or preventing a change that is underway. This can often cause…

Implementation Risk Jonathan Poland

Implementation Risk

Implementation risk refers to the potential negative consequences that a business may face as a result of difficulties or failures…

Leadership Development Jonathan Poland

Leadership Development

Leadership development is the process of helping employees develop the necessary skills and competencies to take on leadership roles within…