What is the Broken Window Fallacy?

What is the Broken Window Fallacy?

What is the Broken Window Fallacy? Jonathan Poland

The broken window fallacy refers to the idea that the economic benefits of destructive events, such as wars and natural disasters, are overstated. While the spending associated with these events can boost a nation’s GDP, this does not necessarily translate into real economic growth or prosperity. This is because the opportunity cost of such events is often overlooked.

For example, if a nation spends $1 trillion dollars on a war, this may stimulate the economy by paying soldiers and defense contractors. However, this does not take into account the fact that the same amount of money could have been used for other purposes that would have a greater stimulative effect on the economy, such as infrastructure projects or education and training programs.

In addition, destructive events often result in long-term economic costs, such as the loss of human lives, damage to infrastructure and natural resources, and increased debt. These costs can outweigh any short-term economic benefits and ultimately harm a nation’s overall economic prosperity. Overall, the broken window fallacy highlights the importance of considering the full economic costs and benefits of any policy or event, rather than focusing solely on the immediate impact on GDP.

The Parable of the Broken Window is a famous argument by political economist Frederic Bastiat, which was published in 1850. The parable tells the story of a shopkeeper whose shop window is broken by his son. Bastiat argues that the situation is good for the economy because the money spent on repairing the window stimulates economic activity. However, the parable then shows that this argument is a fallacy, as it ignores the opportunity cost of spending money on repairing the window. Specifically, the money that is spent on repairing the window could have been used in more productive ways, such as improving the shop or investing in other opportunities.

The parable highlights the importance of considering the full economic costs and benefits of any action, rather than focusing solely on the immediate effects on economic activity. It serves as a reminder that every decision has opportunity costs, and that it is important to carefully weigh these costs and benefits in order to make the most effective and efficient use of resources.

Learn More
Market Position Jonathan Poland

Market Position

The market position of a brand, product, or service refers to its place in a crowded market. It is the…

Venture Capital Jonathan Poland

Venture Capital

Venture capital is a type of private equity financing that is provided to early-stage, high-risk, high-potential companies. Venture capital is…

What is Risk Communication? Jonathan Poland

What is Risk Communication?

Risk communication involves informing people about potential hazards and the steps that can be taken to prevent or mitigate those…

Strategic Communication Jonathan Poland

Strategic Communication

Strategic communication is the deliberate planning, dissemination, and use of information to influence attitudes, beliefs, and behaviors. It is a…

Business Management Jonathan Poland

Business Management

Business management is the process of overseeing and running a business or organization. This involves a wide range of activities,…

Best Industries for Selling B2G 150 150 Jonathan Poland

Best Industries for Selling B2G

The best industries for companies that want to acquire a government contract or grant are those that are aligned with…

Visual Branding Jonathan Poland

Visual Branding

Visual branding is the use of visual elements, such as color, typography, imagery, and design, to create a cohesive and…

Capital Jonathan Poland


Capital is an asset that is expected to produce future economic value. It is a productive resource that is used…

Disruption Strategy Jonathan Poland

Disruption Strategy

A distribution strategy outlines how a company plans to make its products or services available to customers. This includes not…

Content Database

What is a thought experiment? Jonathan Poland

What is a thought experiment?

A thought experiment is a mental exercise that involves exploring the implications or consequences of a hypothetical idea, story, or…

Professionalism Jonathan Poland


Professionalism is the practice of following the standards and expectations of one’s profession, organization, and role. It involves upholding the…

Operating Model Jonathan Poland

Operating Model

An operating model is a framework that outlines how a business operates. It typically covers how a business produces and…

Net Nuetrality Jonathan Poland

Net Nuetrality

Net neutrality is the principle that all internet traffic should be treated equally, without discrimination or preference given to certain…

Proof of Concept Jonathan Poland

Proof of Concept

A proof of concept (POC) is a demonstration that a certain idea or solution is feasible and likely to be…

Managed Services Jonathan Poland

Managed Services

Managed services refer to a range of IT and business services that are outsourced to a third-party provider. These services…

What is the Iterative Process? Jonathan Poland

What is the Iterative Process?

An iterative process is a method of working through a problem or project by repeating a series of steps, each…

Alcon Jonathan Poland


Alcon is a global medical company that is focused on developing and manufacturing innovative products to improve the lives of…

Product Benefits Jonathan Poland

Product Benefits

A product benefit is the value that a customer derives from a product or service. It is what makes the…