strategy

What is a thought experiment?

What is a thought experiment? Jonathan Poland

A thought experiment is a mental exercise that involves exploring the implications or consequences of a hypothetical idea, story, or procedure. It is a way of examining an idea or concept in a systematic and logical manner, without the need for a physical experiment. Thought experiments are often used in scientific fields as a way to explore complex or abstract concepts, and they have played a role in many significant scientific discoveries. They can be used to test the logic of an idea, to challenge assumptions, or to establish principles that can be used in problem solving or decision making. Thought experiments can range from simple, solvable problems to more speculative and open-ended ideas that require imagination and speculation. They are a useful tool for examining ideas and concepts in a flexible and lightweight manner.

Here are a few examples of thought experiments:

  1. Schrödinger’s cat: This thought experiment, proposed by physicist Erwin Schrödinger in 1935, involves imagining a cat in a sealed box with a device that has a 50% chance of releasing poison gas. The idea is to explore the concept of quantum superposition, which suggests that a particle can exist in multiple states at the same time until it is observed.
  2. The trolley problem: This thought experiment, proposed by philosopher Philippa Foot in 1967, involves a trolley that is heading towards a group of people on a track. The idea is to consider whether it is morally acceptable to divert the trolley onto a different track where one person is standing, in order to save the lives of the group.
  3. The Chinese Room: This thought experiment, proposed by philosopher John Searle in 1980, involves imagining a person who speaks only English being placed in a room with a large book of instructions written in Chinese. The idea is to explore whether a machine can truly understand language, or if it is simply following a set of pre-programmed rules.
  4. The paradox of the ravens: This thought experiment, proposed by logician Carl Gustav Hempel in the 1940s, involves considering the statement “All ravens are black.” The idea is to explore the concept of induction, or the process of making generalizations based on observations.
  5. The grandfather paradox: This thought experiment, proposed by science fiction writer René Barjavel in 1943, involves imagining a person traveling back in time and killing their own grandfather before they were born. The idea is to explore the concept of time travel and the potential paradoxes that could arise.

Types of Win-Win

Types of Win-Win Jonathan Poland

Win-win, also known as mutually beneficial, refers to a situation or plan that has the potential to benefit all parties involved. In contrast to a win-lose approach, which focuses on one party’s success at the expense of the other, a win-win approach seeks to find a solution that benefits everyone. This can involve finding common ground, compromising, or creatively finding ways to meet the needs of all parties. A win-win approach is often more effective in building relationships and achieving objectives, as it creates a sense of collaboration and mutual benefit rather than conflict or competition. However, it is important to recognize that not all situations can be win-win, and it may be necessary to consider other factors such as fairness or long-term sustainability. The following are illustrative examples of win-win.

Negotiations

A sales person plans for the other side to negotiate a deep discount so that they can feel they have won. This plan involves a large initial price demand so that the final deal is still profitable.

Strategy

A firm is developing a technology that they hope will become an industry standard. They release it as open source hoping that competitors will also adopt it. The firm feels that if the technology becomes dominant, they have the capability to lead the industry as they have competitive advantages beyond what was released as open source.

Leadership

A leader helps everyone they lead to develop to their full potential. In some cases, this means supporting talent that is clearly going to surpass the leader with time. The benefit to the leader is that they develop a strong network of talented individuals that may be relatively loyal. By not feeling threatened by talent, the leader can get more done against a competitor who is always crushing the threats around them and wasting their talent.

Games

Games can be designed to be win-win such that there is no enemy to defeat. For example, an obstacle course that is impossible for an individual to complete without cooperating with others.

Economy

Trade between nations is thought to be win-win as it allows each nation to develop in areas of comparative advantage while importing goods where it has a comparative disadvantage. For example, a nation that is good at producing coffee but terrible at growing rice, benefits from exporting coffee and importing rice.

Quality of Life

Regulations designed to improve quality of life are often portrayed as being a negative for the economy. This isn’t necessarily true. Environmental regulations can spark new industries in areas such as clean energy. A higher minimum wage can benefit the economy by sparking consumer spending. Consumer protection can improve the quality of products and their competitiveness on international markets.

Security

It is a false dichotomy that we must give up privacy to have security. For example, encrypting data improves both information security and privacy. Strategies such as natural surveillance can both improve quality of life and security. Security strategies that require society to give up things it values may be a failure of imagination as opposed to an inherent win-lose situation.

Over-positioning

Over-positioning Jonathan Poland

Over-positioning refers to the practice of positioning a brand in a way that is too narrow or limited, potentially limiting its appeal to consumers. This can occur when a brand focuses too heavily on a specific product feature or aspect of its identity, to the exclusion of other important considerations.

For example, if a brand positions itself as the most affordable option in its category, it may appeal to price-sensitive consumers. However, this positioning strategy may also limit the brand’s appeal to customers who are willing to pay a premium for higher-quality products. Similarly, a brand that positions itself as the most luxurious option in its category may appeal to high-end consumers, but may not be as attractive to more budget-conscious shoppers.

Over-positioning can also occur when a brand becomes too closely associated with a particular product or service. For example, if a brand is known primarily for a single product, it may be difficult for it to successfully expand into other categories or markets. This can limit the brand’s growth potential and make it more vulnerable to competition.

To avoid over-positioning, it’s important for brands to take a holistic approach to their positioning strategy, considering all relevant factors such as target audience, competitive landscape, and overall business goals. By taking a more balanced approach to positioning, brands can better position themselves to appeal to a wider range of consumers and better protect themselves against the risks of over-positioning. The following are illustrative examples.

Functions
Functions that don’t draw much interest. For example, late model VCRs that featured advanced video editing features for a premium price.

Features
Features that few customers find interesting or useful. For example, including an overhyped technology in a product that doesn’t need it such as artificial intelligence for a can opener.

Quality
A high quality item in a market where customers are primarily concerned with price. For example, printer paper made with an exotic wood such that it has a much higher price than average.

Variety
Excessive variety that doesn’t attract interest. For example, standard pens available in 50 colors when most customers want blue, black and red.

Style
Styles that appeal to a small niche that isn’t enough to support sales.

Identity
A brand identity with an excessively small target market. For example, a brand of electronics for extreme weather golfers.

Tastes
Exotic flavors that few customers are brave enough to try such as a watermelon flavored rice ball.

Sizes
Package sizes that customer’s don’t need such as an unusually small bottle of water.

Rebranding

Rebranding Jonathan Poland

Rebranding is the process of making significant changes to a company’s brand in order to alter the way it is perceived by customers and the wider market. There are a variety of reasons why a company might choose to rebrand, including the desire to modernize their product or image, address customer confusion, move away from a negative legacy, or reflect a change in business strategy.

The process of rebranding typically involves updating a company’s logo, visual identity, messaging, and marketing efforts. This can be a major undertaking, and companies often need to carefully consider their target audience, competitive landscape, and overall business goals when developing a rebranding strategy.

Rebranding can have a number of benefits for companies. It can help to attract new customers, increase brand awareness and recognition, and improve customer perceptions of the brand. However, it’s important for companies to be mindful of the potential risks and challenges of rebranding, such as the potential for customer confusion or resistance to change.

Overall, rebranding can be a powerful tool for companies looking to refresh their image or reposition themselves in the market. By carefully planning and executing a rebranding strategy, companies can make significant changes to their brand and improve their chances of success. The following are common elements of rebranding.

Brand Name

Changing a brand name. For example, consolidating a series of brands in a brand family. Firms invest significant resources in achieving brand recognition such that changing your primary brand name is viewed as a drastic action that is only performed to repair a negative reputation.

Visual Branding

Changes to the visual symbols of a brand such as colors, shapes, typography, logos, packaging, promotional styling and environments.

Brand Identity

Brand identity is everything a firm wants to be in the eyes of customers. This starts with a brand concept that represents the basic idea behind a brand. Brand identity is difficult to communicate and can often change without customers noticing. For example, it might take a firm a decade before most customers recognize a major shift in a firm’s mission and vision.

Brand Legacy

Rebranding is often intended to escape the negative legacy of a brand such as poor sustainability practices or association with an out-of-date technology, fashion or product. However, in some cases a rebranding may be intended to highlight a firm’s legacy. For example, a candy company that rebrands with old fashioned logos to highlight that the brand has been part of a culture for decades.

Brand Promise

A brand promise is a short statement resembling a slogan that communicates what customers can expect of your brand. This is designed to be direct, short and memorable.

Authentic Branding

An attempt to actually change as a company as opposed to a change to brand image that doesn’t reflect underlying realities. For example, a power company that actually launches a serious program of environmental stewardship as opposed to adopting a green logo without any actual changes to strategy and operations.

Internal Branding

In cases of authentic branding, rebranding may begin internally to get employees on board with a new mission and vision.

Customer Experience

Changes to customer experience such as redesigned products and services. For example, a bicycle helmet company that rebrands after a series of safety incidents may redesign its helmets to be safer.

Pricing & Distribution

Elements of the marketing mix such as pricing and distribution may be changed along with a rebranding. For example, an ecommerce company that opens new physical shops may change its slogan and visual branding.

Promotion

It is common to promote a rebranding with extensive advertising campaigns and other promotional efforts.

Storytelling

Storytelling is the art of making information interesting. For example, a firm that wants to promote its brand legacy that captures and communicates interesting anecdotes about the firm’s past.

Experimentation

Rebranding an established brand is a high risk proposition that tends to have a high rate of failure. As such, it is common to experiment and measure results before scaling a brand change.

White Labeling

White Labeling Jonathan Poland

White label refers to products or services that are produced and designed by one company specifically for the purpose of being rebranded and sold by another company. This approach allows businesses to offer a range of products or services to their customers without having to invest in the research, development, and production of these items themselves. Instead, they can simply purchase white label products or services from a supplier and rebrand them as their own.

There are several advantages to using white label products or services. One of the main benefits is that it allows businesses to quickly and easily expand their product or service offerings without having to invest significant resources in development. This can be particularly useful for small businesses or startups that may not have the necessary expertise or resources to develop their own products. Additionally, white label products or services can often be purchased at a lower cost than if a company were to develop the item themselves, making it a more cost-effective option.

However, there are also some potential drawbacks to white label branding. One disadvantage is that companies may have less control over the quality of the products or services they are offering, as they are reliant on the supplier to provide these. Additionally, companies using white label products or services may have a harder time building a unique brand identity and differentiating themselves from their competitors.

Overall, the decision to use white label products or services should be carefully considered by businesses based on their specific goals and target audience. In some cases, this approach can be a useful way to quickly and easily expand a product or service offering, while in others it may be more beneficial to invest in developing and promoting a unique brand identity.

Manufacturing

A firm with competitive advantages in manufacturing but no ability to promote and distribute products may specifically design products to be branded by third parties. Such products may be delivered unpackaged or in plain packaging that can be branded with a label.

Brands

In some cases, a firm with deep manufacturing and marketing capabilities will produce products for another brand, such as a store brand. In this situation, the same exact product may end up being sold side-by-side at different prices.

Services

Software services are easily rebranded. It is common for business, infrastructure and consumer information technology to be branded by multiple marketers. For example, a brand selling cloud computing services may be a reseller with no infrastructure or technical capabilities of their own.

Niche Market Examples

Niche Market Examples Jonathan Poland

A niche is a specific group of consumers who have distinct preferences and needs. These groups are often smaller than the overall market, and can represent an opportunity for smaller companies to target and serve a specific customer base. Niches can be found in a variety of industries, and can be defined by a range of factors such as age, demographics, interests, and lifestyles. In some cases, large companies may choose to enter a variety of niches in order to counter growing competition from smaller firms and protect their market share. By targeting and serving specific niches, companies can often differentiate themselves from their competitors and build a loyal customer base. The following are examples of a niche.

Behavior
A mobile device plan for a customer who uses a great deal of bandwidth.

Benefits
A credit card for customers who want a large number of benefits such as various types of insurance.

Culture
An airline that provides authentic Japanese food on its route to Tokyo.

Demographic
Shoes designed to appeal to urban professional women between 21 and 31 years of age.

Enthusiasts
Light and durable bicycles designed for cycling enthusiasts.

Feature Reduction
Removing common features in a product or service that some customers find cumbersome, invasive or annoying. For example, a television remote without cloud based voice search.

Features
Features that most people don’t use but that are important to a small group of customers. For example, a web browser that allows you to configure hotkeys.

Geographic
A restaurant that offers local specialties.

Language
A Korean language television channel offered in the United States.

Lifestyle
Organic food with healthy ingredients.

Occasions
A cake shop that specializes in events such as weddings.

Opinions
A newspaper that targets readers with a particular set of opinions.

Price Sensitivity
A luxury fashion brand that targets customers who aren’t particularly price sensitive.

Risk Tolerance
An unusually safe model of car designed for customers who prioritize safety.

Status
A fashion brand with aspirational products designed to represent social status.

Style
A snowboard brand that targets a particular sense of style in its designs.

Brand Objectives

Brand Objectives Jonathan Poland

Brand objectives refer to the specific goals that a brand is working towards. These goals can be both long-term end-goals, such as increasing revenue or expanding market share, as well as intermediate steps towards these end-goals, such as improving the brand’s image or positioning in the market. In order to effectively achieve their brand objectives, companies often need to develop and implement a range of strategies, including marketing and advertising efforts, product development and innovation, and customer service initiatives. By setting clear brand objectives and working towards them, companies can better align their efforts and resources in order to achieve their desired outcomes. The following are common brand objectives.

Identity & Image
Establishing an identity for a brand in the market. Measured with surveys that discover how a brand is viewed by your target market.

Recognition
The percentage of customers who recognize your brand name and visual symbols such as logo, packaging, brand colors and products.

Awareness
Brand awareness is the percentage of customers who can recall your brand. For example, top of mind awareness is the percentage of customers who name your brand first when given a product category such as “coffee.”

Engagement
A measure of how often customers interact with your brand. Interactions are defined by you and can include things like visiting your website, visiting a location, making an order and reviewing a product.

Brand Loyalty
The number of customers who regularly purchase your brand.

Brand Advocate
The number of customers who recommend your brand to others.

Brand Equity
The estimated value of your brand.

Market Share
The percentage of your target market that are customers.

Margins
Revenue margins of a brand driven by factors such as brand identity, brand awareness, brand legacy and premiumization of products.

Generic Brand

Generic Brand Jonathan Poland

A generic brand is a type of brand that does not have a distinct or unique image. Instead, it is marketed as being equivalent in quality to more expensive, well-known brands, but at a lower price point. Generic brands often have nondescript packaging and brand names that do not stand out, and they are commonly found on the shelves of supermarkets, convenience stores, and other retail outlets alongside more established brands. These brands are often formulated to be similar to the dominant brands in their category, with the aim of offering customers a lower-cost alternative.

Generic branding refers to the practice of using generic or non-proprietary terms to describe a product or service, rather than using a specific brand name. This approach is often used in industries where there are a large number of competitors offering similar products or services.

One of the main advantages of generic branding is that it allows customers to focus on the product or service itself, rather than being swayed by the perceived prestige or reputation of a particular brand. This can be particularly useful in industries where there are many competing brands, as it allows customers to compare products more easily based on their quality and features, rather than being influenced by brand loyalty or image.

Another advantage of generic branding is that it can be more cost-effective for companies. By using generic branding, companies can avoid the costs associated with developing and promoting a specific brand name. This can be particularly beneficial for smaller companies or startups that may not have the resources to invest in extensive branding efforts.

However, there are also some potential drawbacks to using generic branding. One disadvantage is that it can be more difficult for companies to differentiate themselves from their competitors when using generic branding. Additionally, companies may have a harder time building a loyal customer base without a strong brand identity.

Overall, the decision to use generic branding should be carefully considered by companies based on their specific business goals and target audience. In some cases, generic branding may be a useful approach, while in others it may be more beneficial to invest in developing and promoting a specific brand name.

Brand Perception

Brand Perception Jonathan Poland

Brand perception refers to the way that a brand is perceived by its target audience. It’s important for companies to carefully manage their brand perception, as it can have a significant impact on the success of their business. There are several factors that can influence brand perception. One important factor is the quality of the products or services offered by the brand. Customers who have positive experiences with a brand’s products are more likely to view the brand positively. Similarly, negative experiences with a brand’s products can lead to negative perceptions of the brand.

Another factor that can influence brand perception is the brand’s marketing and advertising efforts. The messaging and imagery used by a brand can shape how customers view the brand and its values. For example, a brand that positions itself as eco-friendly and socially responsible is likely to be perceived differently than a brand that focuses on luxury and exclusivity. In addition to product quality and marketing efforts, customer service and interactions with a brand can also shape brand perception. Customers who have positive experiences with a brand’s customer service are more likely to view the brand favorably.

Overall, it’s important for brands to carefully manage their brand perception in order to attract and retain customers. This can involve regularly assessing customer feedback and making efforts to improve products, marketing efforts, and customer interactions.The following are common types of brand perception.

Quality
How well your products fulfill customer needs. For example, a mobile device that is durable, useful and usable.

Value
The amount of quality relative to price such as a mobile device that is perceived as high quality but overpriced.

Visual
The visual appeal of the brand including products and services.

Senses
Beyond visual appeal, smell, taste, touch and sound can make an impression. For example, shampoo that smells good.

Personality
A customer’s overall impression of your brand may be described with the same concepts that are used to describe people. For example, a brand may be thought of as friendly, reliable or stylish.

Reputation & Legacy
Perceptions of the behavior, values and history of a firm.

Status & Culture
The social status and culture that surrounds the brand. For example, a brand that is associated with sailing or snowboarding subcultures.

Internal Controls Jonathan Poland

Internal Controls

Internal controls refer to the structures, processes, practices, reports, measurements, and systems that are implemented within an organization to support…

Change Management Jonathan Poland

Change Management

Change management is the process of planning and implementing changes within an organization. It involves analyzing the current state of…

Variable Expenses Jonathan Poland

Variable Expenses

Variable expenses are expenses that can fluctuate over time, making them more difficult to budget and predict than fixed expenses.…

Risk Culture Jonathan Poland

Risk Culture

Risk culture refers to the values, attitudes, and behaviors related to risk management that are inherent in the culture of…

Regulatory Risk Jonathan Poland

Regulatory Risk

Regulatory risk refers to the risk that a company will face regulatory actions or penalties as a result of non-compliance…

Knowledge Work Jonathan Poland

Knowledge Work

Knowledge work refers to work that involves the creation, use, or application of knowledge and expertise. It is characterized by…

BATNA Jonathan Poland

BATNA

BATNA, or best alternative to a negotiated agreement, is the course of action that a party in a negotiation would…

What is an Intermediary? Jonathan Poland

What is an Intermediary?

An intermediary is a person or organization that acts as a go-between or intermediary for two or more parties in…

Narrative 101 Jonathan Poland

Narrative 101

Sales and marketing are the lifeblood of business and should be integrated into one function to drive business and brand narrative.

Learn More

Risk Response Jonathan Poland

Risk Response

Risk response is the process of addressing identified risks in order to control or mitigate their impact. It is an…

Turnaround Management Jonathan Poland

Turnaround Management

Turnaround management is a specialized form of management that involves developing and implementing strategies and plans to rescue an organization…

Brand Strategy Jonathan Poland

Brand Strategy

Brand strategy is the plan that a company has for building and managing its brand over time. It involves defining…

Grand Strategy Jonathan Poland

Grand Strategy

A grand strategy is a comprehensive and long-term plan of action that encompasses all available options and resources in order…

Qualified Small Business Stock (QSBS) Jonathan Poland

Qualified Small Business Stock (QSBS)

Qualified Small Business Stock (QSBS) refers to a special classification of stock in the United States that offers significant tax…

What is a Tagline? Jonathan Poland

What is a Tagline?

A tagline is a short, catchy phrase that is used to summarize the core message or value proposition of a…

What is FOMO? Jonathan Poland

What is FOMO?

Fear of missing out, also known as FOMO, is a type of motivation that is driven by a fear of…

What is Cost Overrun? Jonathan Poland

What is Cost Overrun?

A cost overrun occurs when the actual cost of completing a task or project exceeds the budget that was allocated…

Promotion Strategies Jonathan Poland

Promotion Strategies

Promotion strategies are communication techniques that aim to sell a product, service or cause. They include advertising, publicity, selling and…