Over-positioning Jonathan Poland

Over-positioning refers to the practice of positioning a brand in a way that is too narrow or limited, potentially limiting its appeal to consumers. This can occur when a brand focuses too heavily on a specific product feature or aspect of its identity, to the exclusion of other important considerations.

For example, if a brand positions itself as the most affordable option in its category, it may appeal to price-sensitive consumers. However, this positioning strategy may also limit the brand’s appeal to customers who are willing to pay a premium for higher-quality products. Similarly, a brand that positions itself as the most luxurious option in its category may appeal to high-end consumers, but may not be as attractive to more budget-conscious shoppers.

Over-positioning can also occur when a brand becomes too closely associated with a particular product or service. For example, if a brand is known primarily for a single product, it may be difficult for it to successfully expand into other categories or markets. This can limit the brand’s growth potential and make it more vulnerable to competition.

To avoid over-positioning, it’s important for brands to take a holistic approach to their positioning strategy, considering all relevant factors such as target audience, competitive landscape, and overall business goals. By taking a more balanced approach to positioning, brands can better position themselves to appeal to a wider range of consumers and better protect themselves against the risks of over-positioning. The following are illustrative examples.

Functions that don’t draw much interest. For example, late model VCRs that featured advanced video editing features for a premium price.

Features that few customers find interesting or useful. For example, including an overhyped technology in a product that doesn’t need it such as artificial intelligence for a can opener.

A high quality item in a market where customers are primarily concerned with price. For example, printer paper made with an exotic wood such that it has a much higher price than average.

Excessive variety that doesn’t attract interest. For example, standard pens available in 50 colors when most customers want blue, black and red.

Styles that appeal to a small niche that isn’t enough to support sales.

A brand identity with an excessively small target market. For example, a brand of electronics for extreme weather golfers.

Exotic flavors that few customers are brave enough to try such as a watermelon flavored rice ball.

Package sizes that customer’s don’t need such as an unusually small bottle of water.

Learn More
Cost Benefit Analysis Jonathan Poland

Cost Benefit Analysis

Cost-benefit analysis (CBA) is a systematic approach to evaluating the costs and benefits of a project, program, or policy to…

Over Planning Jonathan Poland

Over Planning

Over planning refers to the practice of spending excessive amounts of time planning without implementing any of the plans. This…

Is Greed Good? Jonathan Poland

Is Greed Good?

Greed is good is a paraphrased quote that originates with the 1987 film Wall Street. It is important to note…

What is Risk Communication? Jonathan Poland

What is Risk Communication?

Risk communication involves informing people about potential hazards and the steps that can be taken to prevent or mitigate those…

Brand Risk Jonathan Poland

Brand Risk

Brand risk refers to the potential for a brand to lose value or for a new brand to fail in…

Risk Management Techniques Jonathan Poland

Risk Management Techniques

Risk management is the process of identifying, assessing, and prioritizing risks in order to minimize their potential impact on an…

Sales Objections Jonathan Poland

Sales Objections

A sales objection is a concern or hesitation that a customer has about making a purchase. Identifying and addressing these…

Local Marketing Jonathan Poland

Local Marketing

Local marketing refers to any marketing strategy that targets customers in a specific, finely-grained location, such as a city or…

Content Database

Search over 1,000 posts on topics across
business, finance, and capital markets.

First Principles Thinking Jonathan Poland

First Principles Thinking

Overview First principles thinking is a method of reasoning that involves breaking down complex problems into their most basic and…

Economic Opportunity Jonathan Poland

Economic Opportunity

Economic opportunity refers to the support that a society provides to individuals that enables them to thrive in the economy.…

Personal Data Jonathan Poland

Personal Data

Personal data is any information that can be used to identify an individual, including their name, date of birth, address,…

Price Economics Jonathan Poland

Price Economics

Price economics, also known as pricing strategy, is the study of how businesses determine the price of their products and…

Managed Services Jonathan Poland

Managed Services

Managed services refer to a range of IT and business services that are outsourced to a third-party provider. These services…

BATNA Jonathan Poland


BATNA, or best alternative to a negotiated agreement, is the course of action that a party in a negotiation would…

Willingness to Pay Jonathan Poland

Willingness to Pay

Willingness to pay (WTP) is a measure of how much a customer is willing to pay for a product or…

Business Efficiency Jonathan Poland

Business Efficiency

Business efficiency refers to the effectiveness with which a company or organization converts inputs, such as capital, labor, and materials,…

Time to Volume Jonathan Poland

Time to Volume

Time to volume is a marketing metric that measures the time it takes for a new product to go from concept to launch and reach a significant level of sales or usage.