Over-positioning Jonathan Poland

Over-positioning refers to the practice of positioning a brand in a way that is too narrow or limited, potentially limiting its appeal to consumers. This can occur when a brand focuses too heavily on a specific product feature or aspect of its identity, to the exclusion of other important considerations.

For example, if a brand positions itself as the most affordable option in its category, it may appeal to price-sensitive consumers. However, this positioning strategy may also limit the brand’s appeal to customers who are willing to pay a premium for higher-quality products. Similarly, a brand that positions itself as the most luxurious option in its category may appeal to high-end consumers, but may not be as attractive to more budget-conscious shoppers.

Over-positioning can also occur when a brand becomes too closely associated with a particular product or service. For example, if a brand is known primarily for a single product, it may be difficult for it to successfully expand into other categories or markets. This can limit the brand’s growth potential and make it more vulnerable to competition.

To avoid over-positioning, it’s important for brands to take a holistic approach to their positioning strategy, considering all relevant factors such as target audience, competitive landscape, and overall business goals. By taking a more balanced approach to positioning, brands can better position themselves to appeal to a wider range of consumers and better protect themselves against the risks of over-positioning. The following are illustrative examples.

Functions that don’t draw much interest. For example, late model VCRs that featured advanced video editing features for a premium price.

Features that few customers find interesting or useful. For example, including an overhyped technology in a product that doesn’t need it such as artificial intelligence for a can opener.

A high quality item in a market where customers are primarily concerned with price. For example, printer paper made with an exotic wood such that it has a much higher price than average.

Excessive variety that doesn’t attract interest. For example, standard pens available in 50 colors when most customers want blue, black and red.

Styles that appeal to a small niche that isn’t enough to support sales.

A brand identity with an excessively small target market. For example, a brand of electronics for extreme weather golfers.

Exotic flavors that few customers are brave enough to try such as a watermelon flavored rice ball.

Package sizes that customer’s don’t need such as an unusually small bottle of water.

Learn More
What are Field Services? Jonathan Poland

What are Field Services?

Field service involves managing and deploying resources and assets at customer, public, and third-party locations, as well as providing services…

BATNA Jonathan Poland


BATNA, or best alternative to a negotiated agreement, is the course of action that a party in a negotiation would…

Sales Objections Jonathan Poland

Sales Objections

A sales objection is a concern or hesitation that a customer has about making a purchase. Identifying and addressing these…

Nudge Theory Jonathan Poland

Nudge Theory

Nudge theory is the idea that subtle suggestions, choices, and positive reinforcement can be more effective than commands, rules, and…

Production Management Jonathan Poland

Production Management

Production management is the process of planning, organizing, and controlling the production of goods or services. It involves coordinating the…

Algorithmic Accountability Jonathan Poland

Algorithmic Accountability

Algorithmic accountability is the concept of holding algorithms and the organizations that use them accountable for the decisions they make…

Small Business Jonathan Poland

Small Business

A small business is a privately owned and operated company with a small number of employees and relatively low volume…

Total Addressable Market Jonathan Poland

Total Addressable Market

A total addressable market (TAM) is the total potential revenue that a company can generate from its products or services…

What is Reliability? Jonathan Poland

What is Reliability?

Reliability is a measure of the ability of a product or service to perform consistently and predictably over time. It…

Latest Thinking

Qualified Small Business Stock (QSBS) Jonathan Poland

Qualified Small Business Stock (QSBS)

Qualified Small Business Stock (QSBS) refers to a special classification of stock in the United States that offers significant tax…

Barrick Gold Jonathan Poland

Barrick Gold

Barrick Gold Corporation (NYSE: GOLD) is a significant player in the global economy, particularly within the gold mining industry. Its…

Newmont Corporation Jonathan Poland

Newmont Corporation

Newmont Corporation (NYSE: NEM), being the world’s largest gold mining corporation, with extensive operations in mining and production of not…

Gold is Money Jonathan Poland

Gold is Money

Overview The history of gold as money spans thousands of years and has played a pivotal role in the economic…

What is Leadership? Jonathan Poland

What is Leadership?

In the modern business world, where rapid changes, technological advancements, and global challenges are the norm, effective leadership is more…

Product Durability Jonathan Poland

Product Durability

A durable product, often referred to as a durable good, is a product that does not quickly wear out or,…

Durable Competitive Advantage Jonathan Poland

Durable Competitive Advantage

The most important aspect of durability is market fit. Unique super simple products or services that does change much if…

Praxeology Jonathan Poland


Praxeology is the study of human action, particularly as it pertains to decision-making and the pursuit of goals. The term…

Business Models Jonathan Poland

Business Models

Business models define how a company creates, delivers, and captures value. There are numerous business models, each tailored to specific…