Capitalist Realism

Capitalist Realism

Capitalist Realism Jonathan Poland

Capitalist realism is the theory that capitalism is the only economic system that is realistically possible or viable. This term is often used to suggest that defenders of capitalism use the notion of realism as a cover for positions that are cold, unimaginative, or fearful of change.

For example, someone who espouses capitalist realism might argue that socialism or communism is not a realistic alternative to capitalism because it has failed in the past and is not feasible in the current global economic environment. They might also argue that capitalism is the only economic system that can provide the necessary incentives and rewards to drive innovation and economic growth.

Overall, capitalist realism is a theory that is often used to argue that there is no realistic alternative to capitalism. While this theory has its supporters, it is also highly contested and has been challenged by those who argue that alternative economic systems are not only possible, but also necessary in order to address the many challenges and inequalities of capitalism. The following are illustrative examples of capitalist realism.

Overwhelming Success

The argument that capitalism is an overwhelming success such as the observation that close to all economic production that supports the current world population of 7.6 billion people stems from capitalist economic systems. All countries, with a handful of exceptions such as North Korea, currently have a capitalist system of one flavor or another including social market economies such as Sweden.

There is No Alternative

The argument that the main alternatives to capitalism such as communism were tried with disastrous results such as the Great Chinese Famine of 1959 – 1961 that claimed the lives of an estimated 20 to 50 million people.

Quality of Life

The observation that the global capitalist economy has raised quality of life on a global basis. For example, no country has a lower expectancy than the country with the highest life expectancy in 1800. World life expectancy increased from 29 years in 1800 to 72.6 in 2019.

Too Big To Fail

The argument that global systems, nations and populations tend towards panic when their capitalist economies experience a few quarters of negative growth as in the case of a recession. From this it can be argued that societies and their populations aren’t inclined towards toppling capitalism but are rather likely to do whatever is necessary to defend it.

Socialist Idealism

The argument that supporters of socialism have a tendency to promote magical thinking that doesn’t align to historical realities or human behavior. For example, the argument that communism would somehow clean up the environment despite the history of ecological mismanagement and disasters in historical communist nations.

Socialist Elites

The argument that communism doesn’t create equality that it just replaces a capitalist elite with a bureaucratic elite that implements central planning of the entire economy.

Human Nature

The argument that the profit motive aligns with human motivations more than working hard day after day for the “greater good” of society in general. This would suggest that productivity, innovation and quality would go into a steep decline without the economic rights and freedoms that form the basis for capitalism.

Learning From History

The argument that modern socialists haven’t learned from history or that they claim “this time it will be different” without sufficient explanation and data.

Capitalist Pragmatism

The argument that problems with capitalism such as inequality and environmental destruction can be solved within the capitalist system itself. For example, taxing the super wealthy and redistributing these resources as education, healthcare and basic income programs. Environmental problems could be addressed with a market for economic bads that caps pollution at some sustainable level.

Socialist Pragmatism

Most developed nations use taxation as a form of limited income redistribution in the form of public services and direct payments such as welfare benefits. This is known as democratic socialism — a variant of socialism that uses the profit motive and markets to achieve efficiency and productivity with social services funded by taxation. This could be described as socialist pragmatism that seeks achievable improvements to a dominant system that isn’t going to be easy to completely replace.

Participation

The more people who participate in capitalism and benefit from it, the more unlikely alternatives may seem. As such, capitalist realism feels all the more realistic in a society with a large and thriving middle class and bourgeoisie. As both of these classes own capital they have little interest in overthrowing capitalism. Without wide participation, capitalist realism begins to look more and more idealistic as it becomes an obvious choice for the masses to simply seize the capital of a relatively small elite.

Complacency

Capitalist realism may create a complacency amongst global elites that their position is secure no matter how far they push things such as rent seeking, crony capitalism, anti-competitive practices, conspicuous consumption, environmental destruction or aggressive tax structures and strategies. Mark Fisher viewed capitalist realism as an oppressive force that may backfire potentially toppling capitalism.

Cold Logic

The term capitalist realism is often used to describe the excesses of capitalism such as cold logic whereby money is used to model human problems without concern for human aspects of the problem. For example, evaluating education programs in terms of the salaries of graduates without considerations such as art, culture and the value of knowledge to humanity.

Failure of Imagination

As capitalism is pervasive and dominant it can be argued that we have acquired a learned inability to imagine systems beyond it.

Defense of the Status Quo

Capitalist realism is a type of defense of the status quo whereby people resist change to a system that sustains them. This isn’t necessarily irrational if there is some reasonable argument for sustaining the present system. Those who view capitalism as an oppressive or destructive force may certainly feel that this is irrational but this requires evidence and debate. In other words, it would be lazy to simply write off capitalists as being unimaginative, biased and fearful of change.

Learn More…

Working Style Jonathan Poland

Working Style

Working style refers to an individual’s preferred approach to performing their job…

Telecommuting Jonathan Poland

Telecommuting

Telecommuting, also known as remote work or working from home, is a…

What is Cultural Fit? Jonathan Poland

What is Cultural Fit?

Culture fit refers to the compatibility of a candidate’s attitudes and experiences…

What is the Iterative Process? Jonathan Poland

What is the Iterative Process?

An iterative process is a method of working through a problem or…

Durable Competitive Advantage Jonathan Poland

Durable Competitive Advantage

The most important aspect of durability is market fit. Unique super simple…

Job Orientation Jonathan Poland

Job Orientation

Job orientation, also known as onboarding, is the process of introducing new…

Administrative Skills Jonathan Poland

Administrative Skills

Administrative skills are abilities and personality traits that enable a person to…

Customer Service Principles Jonathan Poland

Customer Service Principles

Customer service principles are guidelines that an organization follows to shape its…

Business Transformation Jonathan Poland

Business Transformation

Business transformation is the process of fundamentally changing the way an organization…

Jonathan Poland © 2023

Search the Database

Over 1,000 posts on topics ranging from strategy to operations, innovation to finance, technology to risk and much more…

Onboarding Jonathan Poland

Onboarding

Onboarding is the process of introducing a new employee to an organization…

IT Operations Jonathan Poland

IT Operations

IT operations involves the delivery and management of information technology services, including…

Strategic Partnership Jonathan Poland

Strategic Partnership

A strategic partnership is a relationship between two or more organizations that…

Organic Growth Jonathan Poland

Organic Growth

Organic growth refers to an increase in revenue that is generated through…

Sales Jonathan Poland

Sales

Sales is the process of establishing relationships with potential customers, discovering their…

Gap Analysis Jonathan Poland

Gap Analysis

A gap analysis is a method used to determine the distance between…

Selling Points Jonathan Poland

Selling Points

Selling points are the key features or benefits of a product that…

Digital Goods Jonathan Poland

Digital Goods

Digital goods are products that are delivered and consumed in digital form,…

Camping Strategy Jonathan Poland

Camping Strategy

Camping strategy is the practice of a using a geographical location as…